December 2007
Field Crops 28.45-52
To spray or not to spray –
Will foliar fungicide be routine in the new corn production economics?
Joe Lauer, Corn Agronomist
PDF Version
2007 Summary of Wisconsin research on foliar
fungicides
In 2007, many acres of corn in Wisconsin were sprayed mid-season with fungicides,
strobilurin or a strobilurin/triazole combination, (in Iowa and Illinois an estimated
six million acres of corn were sprayed). Most acres applied had little or no disease
at the time of application. Reasons for spraying vary and include the high price
of corn, potential to control diseases, and a possibility of improved yield from
"plant health" benefits. Until this year, fungicide applications to production
cornfields were rarely practiced because they were not profitable. Many of the hybrids
grown today have good overall tolerance to foliar diseases.
Results of fungicide trials have been mixed in Wisconsin (Table 1). In 2 of 11 trials
a significant yield response occurred that covered the fungicide cost.
Some plant damage has been reported when using fungicide, some of it severe. There
is NO confirmed correlation between damage and fungicide. There is no real evidence
that continuous corn (no-and strip-till), routinely needs fungicide more often,
but Anthracnose and Gray Leaf Spot inoculant potential is higher. Fungicide damage
was related to weather and crop conditions in 2007, but it could happen again, so
you may not want to apply pre-tassel.
The 2008 growing season is several months away, but decisions are already being
made regarding purchase of fungicides. Fungicides should be used as a "tool" (along
with other IPM practices) – to control diseases that are present and/or almost certain
to be a problem. Consider the following factors before spraying:
-
hybrid susceptibility,
-
disease pressure at VT,
-
weather conditions at VT and during grain fill,
-
previous crop,
-
the amount of crop residue present in the field,
-
fungicide and application cost ,
-
grain price, and
-
read directions and restrictions on product label.
In general, a fungicide application is not recommended on resistant hybrids. On
susceptible hybrids, a fungicide application may be warranted if disease is present
on the third leaf below the ear leaf or higher on 50 percent of the plants at tasseling.
With intermediate hybrids, a fungicide need only be applied if conditions are favorable
for disease development. Spray if disease is present on the third leaf below the
ear leaf or higher on 50 percent of the plants at tasseling, and the weather is
warm and humid, and the field has a history of Gray Leaf Spot and/or Anthracnose,
and >35 percent corn residue is present.
Table 1. Corn and Headline™ fungicide response in Wisconsin. All applications were
applied at labeled rates at VT. An asterisk indicates significance at P < 0.10.
Fungicide cost is ~ $22 an acre (cost of product and application), the breakeven
yield response was a minimum of 6 bu/acre, assuming a corn price of $3.75
|
Year
|
Previous Crop
|
Tillage
|
No Fungicide
|
With Fungicide
|
Fungicide Increase
|
Did it pay?
|
|
|
|
------- bushels per acre -------
|
|
2007
|
Corn
|
No-till
|
216
|
222
|
6
|
?
|
|
Soybean
|
No-till
|
203
|
230
|
27*
|
Yes
|
|
Wheat
|
No-till
|
205
|
210
|
5
|
No
|
|
Soybean
|
No-till
|
206
|
208
|
2
|
No
|
2006
|
Soybean
|
Chisel
|
226
|
229
|
3
|
No
|
|
Corn
|
Chisel
|
214
|
217
|
3
|
No
|
|
Corn
|
Chisel
|
227
|
227
|
0
|
No
|
2005
|
Corn
|
Chisel
|
181
|
186
|
5
|
No
|
|
Soybean
|
Chisel
|
199
|
211
|
12
|
?
|
|
Soybean
|
Chisel
|
212
|
213
|
1
|
No
|
2004
|
Soybean
|
Chisel
|
200
|
211
|
11*
|
Yes
|