Variability of Planting Date on Corn Grain Yield, Moisture and Grower Return
April 9, 1998 5(5):27-28
Joe Lauer, Corn Agronomist
This year producers might consider planting corn earlier than normal. Producers,
who plant corn early, are concerned about frost, poor emergence, and early plant
growth. Producers, who plant later, wonder what maturities to plant, and how late
planting affects final grain yield and moisture (more about this in the next WCM
issue). Planting full-season hybrids early is highly recommended because the entire
growing season can be used. Physiological maturity can be reached before growth
stops because of frost, and some field drying of corn can occur allowing greater
profit margin. These considerations are important for all corn producers, but are
even more important for producers on the northern fringes of the Corn Belt where
the growing season often is limiting.
Table 1 shows the effect of planting date on various corn hybrids between 1991 and
1997 at Arlington, WI. In some years, yield was affected by earlier planting dates.
However, grower return was typically best early in the planting season. Optimum
planting dates range from May 1 to May 7 in southern and northern Wisconsin, respectively.
There is some yield risk with early planting dates, but this is often made up by
lower drying costs. If corn is planted prior to 20 and 30 April in southern and
northern Wisconsin, respectively, the decision to begin planting should be based
on soil temperature and field conditions. After 20 and 30 April, corn planting should
proceed as rapidly as possible and be completed by 12 May for southern Wisconsin
and 15 May for northern Wisconsin. Otherwise, corn producers will suffer significant
yield penalties with further delays in planting.
Table 1. Corn response to planting date between 1991 and 1997 at Arlington, WI.
|
Year
|
Planting date
|
Grain yield
|
Grain moisture
|
GrowerReturn
|
|
|
Bu/A
|
%
|
$/A
|
|
|
|
|
|
1997
|
April 18
|
198
|
24
|
497
|
|
May 05
|
165
|
27
|
406
|
|
May 13
|
190
|
26
|
471
|
|
May 20
|
172
|
28
|
421
|
|
June 02
|
164
|
31
|
392
|
|
June 10
|
134
|
27
|
331
|
|
June 19
|
107
|
34
|
249
|
|
July 01
|
24
|
55
|
67
|
|
|
|
|
|
1996
|
April 26
|
178
|
25
|
445
|
|
May 01
|
169
|
25
|
420
|
|
May 05
|
161
|
26
|
397
|
|
May 10
|
173
|
27
|
426
|
|
May 20
|
141
|
26
|
350
|
|
June 13
|
141
|
30
|
338
|
|
|
|
|
|
1995
|
April 20
|
156
|
17
|
413
|
|
May 01
|
153
|
17
|
405
|
|
May 15
|
152
|
18
|
401
|
|
May 19
|
150
|
19
|
393
|
|
May 20
|
145
|
20
|
378
|
|
June 09
|
105
|
23
|
267
|
|
|
|
|
|
1994
|
April 20
|
169
|
19
|
442
|
|
May 03
|
167
|
20
|
433
|
|
May 10
|
165
|
22
|
423
|
|
May 20
|
170
|
24
|
427
|
|
June 01
|
137
|
33
|
323
|
|
June 10
|
106
|
29
|
256
|
|
June 22
|
50
|
45
|
105
|
|
|
|
|
|
1993
|
April 23
|
152
|
30
|
367
|
|
April 30
|
149
|
31
|
355
|
|
May 10
|
131
|
36
|
301
|
|
May 19
|
123
|
29
|
300
|
|
June 01
|
102
|
35
|
239
|
|
June 10
|
97
|
23
|
245
|
|
June 22
|
45
|
39
|
101
|
|
|
|
|
|
1992
|
April 30
|
180
|
29
|
434
|
|
May 07
|
182
|
31
|
431
|
|
May 14
|
161
|
33
|
375
|
|
May 21
|
129
|
40
|
284
|
|
May 28
|
121
|
44
|
258
|
|
June 04
|
73
|
49
|
149
|
|
June 10
|
64
|
42
|
139
|
|
June 23
|
29
|
54
|
58
|
|
|
|
|
|
1991
|
April 20
|
168
|
30
|
403
|
|
May 01
|
172
|
29
|
416
|
|
May 09
|
180
|
32
|
426
|
|
May 20
|
158
|
25
|
396
|
|
June 01
|
145
|
31
|
346
|
|
June 10
|
106
|
29
|
255
|
|
June 18
|
90
|
32
|
211
|
Grower return to management = (Grain yield x Grain price) minus treatment costs
Assumptions included:
Grain price = $2.75 per bushel
Drying cost = $0.02 per moisture point above 15.5%
Hauling cost = $0.04 per bushel
Handling cost = $0.02 per bushel
|